Ad #7659344
MLS #11738160
Set on an oversized 0.62-acre parcel, formed from the merger of
338 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
$3,395,000
4Beds
2Baths
3,000Sqft
0.62Acres
About this property
Set on an oversized 0.62-acre parcel, formed from the merger of two original lots, 338 Main Street occupies a distinguished position along Sag Harbor Village's coveted Captain's Row, directly across from Otter Pond with serene water views and private access via John Street. Upon entry, gracious Greek Revival and Italianate archways create a sense of arrival, guiding a central axis through the home toward an impressive fireplace. The interiors retain notable period architectural elements, including marble fireplaces and well-proportioned rooms that reflect the craftsmanship and scale of Sag Harbor's maritime era. Dating to circa 1830-1840, this historic residence presents a rare opportunity to restore and thoughtfully reimagine a significant village property. Just shy of 3,000 square feet, the current home offers generous living spaces including four bedrooms, an oversized kitchen, an inviting sunroom, and a detached garage, providing both immediate comfort and exceptional long-term potential. Rich in history and architectural character, the home offers exceptional potential for restoration and expansion. The expansive grounds provide ample space to create a substantial Captain's Row estate, with opportunities for a pool, garage or carriage house, pool house, lower-level expansion, and enhanced landscaping for privacy and outdoor living. A rare offering combining historic provenance, scale, and future possibility, 338 Main Street represents a unique opportunity within the heart of Sag Harbor Village.
Property Features
4 Beds
2 Baths
3,000 Sqft
Built in 1840
0.62 Acres
2 Stories
Forced Air, Oil
$11,312 / yr property tax
Suffolk County
Additional Photos
Contact Information
Erin Keneally
Compass
212-913-9058
Location
Listing Agent: Erin Keneally 212-913-9058
Broker: Compass 212-913-9058 Listing Site
Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Broker: Compass 212-913-9058 Listing Site
Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
BeachHouse.com
Printed Aug 11, 2026
Photo Gallery
$3,395,000
4
Beds
2
Baths
3,000
Sqft
338 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
By contacting this agent you agree to these Terms and Conditions.
MLS# 11738160
Set on an oversized 0.62-acre parcel, formed from the merger of
$3,395,000
338 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
4
Beds
2
Baths
3,000
Sqft
0.62
Acres
$3,395,000
338 Main St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963
4 Beds
2 Baths
3,000 Sqft
0.62 Acres
Set on an oversized 0.62-acre parcel, formed from the merger of two original lots, 338 Main Street occupies a distinguished position along Sag Harbor Village's coveted Captain's Row, directly across from Otter Pond with serene water views and private access via John Street. Upon entry, gracious Greek Revival and Italianate archways create a sense of arrival, guiding a central axis through the home toward an impressive fireplace. The interiors retain notable period architectural elements, including marble fireplaces and well-proportioned rooms that reflect the craftsmanship and scale of Sag Harbor's maritime era. Dating to circa 1830-1840, this historic residence presents a rare opportunity to restore and thoughtfully reimagine a significant village property. Just shy of 3,000 square feet, the current home offers generous living spaces including four bedrooms, an oversized kitchen, an inviting sunroom, and a detached garage, providing both immediate comfort and exceptional long-term potential. Rich in history and architectural character, the home offers exceptional potential for restoration and expansion. The expansive grounds provide ample space to create a substantial Captain's Row estate, with opportunities for a pool, garage or carriage house, pool house, lower-level expansion, and enhanced landscaping for privacy and outdoor living. A rare offering combining historic provenance, scale, and future possibility, 338 Main Street represents a unique opportunity within the heart of Sag Harbor Village.
102 days
on BeachHouse.com
87
views
0
saves
Property Details
HOME DETAILS
4 Beds
2 Baths
3,000 Sqft
Built in 1840
0.62 Acres
2 Stories
INTERIOR
Forced Air, Oil
FINANCIAL & COMMUNITY
$11,312 / yr property tax
Suffolk County
See More Details
Location
Mortgage Calculator
Ad Statistics
Ad Number
7659344
Viewed
87 times
Listing Status
Active
Added
May 01, 2026
Last Refreshed
Jul 03, 2026 06:17:28 PM
Listing Information
Data Source
My State MLS
Source Property ID
11738160
Listing Agent: Erin Keneally 212-913-9058
Broker: Compass 212-913-9058 Listing Site
Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Broker: Compass 212-913-9058 Listing Site
Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.
Request Information
Start advertising today
Explore options for real estate agents and homeowners advertising on BeachHouse.com
Sell Your Home
Explore Similar Properties
