Back to Search Back to Listing

Ad #6698852

MLS #11584943

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500

58 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

$4,995,000

4Beds

3Baths

2,500Sqft

0.86Acres

About this property

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 sq. ft. residence offers breathtaking water vistas and unforgettable sunsets. The first level features three bedrooms, two of which open directly onto a sheltered patio with panoramic bay views, along with a full bathroom. Upstairs, an expansive living room with a cozy wood-burning stove flows seamlessly into the dining area and fully equipped kitchen. Sliders open onto a generous wrap-around deck overlooking the water, perfect for entertaining or relaxing. The primary bedroom is also on this level with its own bath and private access to the deck, and there is an additional full bathroom on this floor for convenience. A versatile loft/office occupies the third floor, showcasing sweeping water views. Additional amenities include an attached garage for storage, an unfinished basement useful for storage, an outdoor shower, and direct water access ideal for kayaking or mooring a small boat out front. Just moments from the harbor and town center, this property is a rare Montauk retreat combining comfort, privacy, and unmatched sunsets.

Property Features

4 Beds

3 Baths

2,500 Sqft

Built in 1985

0.86 Acres

2 Stories

Has Fireplace

Electric (Heating), Baseboard

Suffolk County

Additional Photos

Contact Information

Chris Coleman

Compass

212-913-9058

Location

Listing Agent: Chris Coleman 212-913-9058
Broker: Compass 212-913-9058 Listing Site
Copyright © 2026 My State MLS. All rights reserved. All information provided by the listing agent/broker is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified.

BeachHouse.com

Printed Aug 11, 2026

Photo Gallery

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 1

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 2

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 3

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 4

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 5

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 6

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 7

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 8

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 9

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 10

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 11

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 12

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 13

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 14

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 15

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 16

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 17

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 18

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 19

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 20

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 21

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 22

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 23

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 24

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 25

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 26

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 27

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 28

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 29

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 30

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500 - photo 31

$4,995,000

Beds

Baths

2,500

Sqft

58 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

By contacting this agent you agree to these Terms and Conditions.

Home New York Montauk

MLS# 11584943

Home For Sale

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500

$4,995,000

58 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

Beds

Baths

2,500

Sqft

0.86

Acres

$4,995,000

58 Firestone Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

4 Beds

3 Baths

2,500 Sqft

0.86 Acres

309 days

on BeachHouse.com

313

views

saves

Property Details

HOME DETAILS

4 Beds

3 Baths

2,500 Sqft

Built in 1985

0.86 Acres

2 Stories

INTERIOR

Has Fireplace

Electric (Heating), Baseboard

FINANCIAL & COMMUNITY

Suffolk County

See More Details

Location

Open in Google Maps

Mortgage Calculator

Ad Statistics

Ad Number

6698852

Viewed

313 times

Listing Status

Active

Added

Oct 06, 2025

Last Refreshed

Jul 03, 2026 06:17:28 PM

Listing Information

Data Source

My State MLS

Source Property ID

11584943

Request Information

Send Me New Listings

By proceeding, you authorize Dream Home Network Inc., its service providers (including real estate professionals such as Brokers, Listing Agents, Buyers Agents, and local referral partners), its affiliates, and other real estate professionals that may not be associated with Dream Home Network, to contact you using the contact details you provided, via email, phone call, and text (SMS), including using automated dialing technology and prerecorded and artificial voice, for marketing or advertising purposes, including contacting you about your inquiry and other home-related matters. You understand that your consent to the foregoing is not a condition of any purchase. Message and data rates may apply. This consent applies even if you are on a corporate, state or national Do Not Call list. Dream Home Network Inc. may share information about your recent and future site activity with its affiliates and service providers (including real estate professionals such as Brokers, Listing Agents, Buyers Agents, and local referral partners) to help them better understand what you are looking for in a property. To opt-out at any time you can reply "STOP" or contact Dream Home Network Inc. at csv@dreamhomenetwork.com.

Start advertising today

Explore options for real estate agents and homeowners advertising on BeachHouse.com

Sell Your Home

Explore Similar Properties

For Sale

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 1

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 2

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 3

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 4

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 5

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 6

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 7

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 8

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 9

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 10

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 11

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 12

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 13

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 14

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 15

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 16

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 17

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 18

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 19

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 20

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 21

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 22

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 23

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 24

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 25

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 26

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 27

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 28

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 29

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 30

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 31

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 32

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 33

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 34

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 35

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 36

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 37

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 38

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 39

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 40

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 41

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 42

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 43

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 44

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 45

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 46

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 47

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 48

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 49

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set - photo 50

$4,699,000

4 Beds | 4.0 Baths | 2,400 Sqft

15 Edgemere St, Montauk, NY 11954

Elegant Montauk Retreat With Sunset Water Views. Privately set

Added: 04/10/2026 • Updated: 07/07/2026

For Sale

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 1

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 2

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 3

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 4

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 5

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 6

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 7

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 8

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 9

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 10

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 11

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 12

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 13

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 14

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 15

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 16

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 17

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 18

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 19

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 20

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 21

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 22

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 23

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 24

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood - photo 25

$4,500,000

4 Beds | 3.0 Baths | 2,158 Sqft

22 Caswell Rd, Montauk, NY 11954

Located in the highly sought-after Ditch Plains neighborhood

Added: 06/19/2026 • Updated: 07/02/2026

For Sale

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 1

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 2

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 3

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 4

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 5

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 6

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 7

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 8

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 9

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 10

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 11

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 12

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 13

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk - photo 14

$4,495,000

4 Beds | 4.0 Baths | 0 Sqft

55 S DAVIS AVE, Montauk, NY 11954

Privacy is becoming increasingly difficult to find in Montauk

Added: 07/02/2026 • Updated: 07/02/2026

Sale Pending

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 1

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 2

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 3

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 4

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 5

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 6

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 7

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 8

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 9

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 10

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 11

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 12

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 13

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 14

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 15

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 16

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 17

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 18

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 19

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 20

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 21

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 22

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 23

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 24

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 25

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 26

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 27

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 28

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 29

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 30

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 31

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 32

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 33

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 34

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 35

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 36

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 37

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 38

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 39

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 40

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 41

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk - photo 42

$4,995,000

4 Beds | 3.0 Baths | 2,100 Sqft

112 Soundview Dr, Montauk, NY 11954

Now presented at a compelling value! Experience Montauk

Added: 12/12/2025 • Updated: 07/09/2026

SEARCH STATES

Alabama Alaska California Connecticut Delaware Florida Georgia Hawaii Louisiana Maine Maryland Mississippi New Hampshire New Jersey New York North Carolina Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina Texas Virginia Washington

SERVICES

Buy Buy Advertise

COMPANY

Testimonials About Us Office Locations

SUPPORT

Help Contact Us

ADDITIONAL MARKETS

LakeHouse.com MountainHomes.com GolfHomes.com BarrierFreeHome.com

Receive notifications for new listings

Dream Home Network Inc.

is committed to ensuring digital accessibility and property listings for individuals with disabilities. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed and should be independently verified. We are continuously working to improve the accessibility of our web experience for everyone, and we welcome feedback and accommodation requests. If you wish to report an issue or seek an accommodation, please let us know.

Dream Home Network Inc. Sells leads to DHN Realty Inc. who holds real estate brokerage licenses in Alabama. Listing agents will be sent notification copy of leads on their listings where Dream Home Network Inc. is provided listings via our Feed Provider as required.

About this property

Property Features

Additional Photos

Contact Information

Location

Tucked away on the shores of Fort Pond Bay, this well-kept 2,500

Property Details

HOME DETAILS

INTERIOR

FINANCIAL & COMMUNITY

Location

Mortgage Calculator

Listing Information

Request Information

Start advertising today

Montauk

Montauk Real Estate Agent Info

About Montauk

FINANCIAL & COMMUNITY

Search Filters

Montauk

Montauk Real Estate Agent Info

About Montauk